top of page

Soft 404: What It Means and How to Fix It

Nov 14
8 min read
A mock Search Console Page indexing report with the row "Soft 404" highlighted, the status this guide explains.

A soft 404 in Search Console means Google thinks the page is empty or missing, even though your server says it loaded fine. Fix it. Either make it a real page with real content, send it to a closely related page with a redirect, or let it return a proper 404 or 410 so Google knows it is gone.


What does "Soft 404" mean?

Every page your server sends comes with a status code: 200 means "here is the page", 404 means "not found". A soft 404 says 200 but looks, to Google, like nothing is there. Google's documentation puts it this way: if the content suggests "an empty page or an error message", Search Console shows a soft 404.


Google's help for this status gives the two halves of the fix: "We recommend returning a 404 response code for truly "not found" pages and adding more information on the page to let us know that it is not a soft 404."


Should you fix a soft 404?

Yes, every time, because a soft 404 is a mixed message. Either the page should exist and needs content, or it should not exist and needs to say so. Which fix depends on what the page was meant to be. Use the table to pick one, then follow the steps further down.


What the page is

Fix

Why

A real page that looks thin or empty to Google

Add real content

Google needs to see it is not an error page

A page that has moved

301 redirect to the new address

Visitors and Google go straight to it

A product or page gone for good, with a close replacement

301 redirect to the replacement

The replacement serves the same need

A page gone for good, with no replacement

Return 404 or 410

Google says a removed page with no replacement is fine as a 404

A page that is fine, but has words like "not available" on it

Reword it

Some platforms say such phrases can read as an error


A decision tree for fixing a soft 404: add real content, set a 301 redirect to the new address or the replacement, return 404 or 410, or reword the page.

From Capron Media: the free Lite subscription

Lite site health panel for a made-up bakery: 3 high, 9 medium and 14 low urgency items across 48 pages checked. Example data.
Example data from a made-up bakery.

Is your site in good shape? See it in plain words

See what on your site needs fixing, counted by urgency, with the top three in plain words. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.



404 vs soft 404: what is the difference?

A 404 is honest: the server says the page is not there. A soft 404 says the page is there, then shows something that looks empty or like an error. Google handles a real 404 cleanly, dropping the address over time. A soft 404 leaves Google to guess, which is why Search Console flags it.



404 (not found)

Soft 404

Status code the server sends

404

200, as if all is well

What the visitor sees

A "page not found" page

An empty page, an error message, or very little

What Google does

Drops the address from the index over time

Flags the page and does not index it

Is it a problem?

Not if the page is gone with no replacement

Yes: the signal and the page disagree

Search Console row

Not found (404)

Soft 404


A side-by-side of a real 404 and a soft 404: the status code each sends, what the visitor sees, what Google does, and the Search Console row each one lands in.

Pages that can trip a soft 404 on small sites

Pages to check first are those that load but have little to show: a category or tag with no items, your site's own search results for a term with no matches, a sold-out product page, and a location page with a heading and nothing else. In our judgement, old addresses redirected to the home page are worth a check too. Check each against the table below.


Page

Why it looks empty to Google

Fix

An empty category, collection or tag

A heading and "no items found"

Add items, or remove the page

Your site's search results with no matches

"No results" on a page that returned 200

Keep search results out of the index

A sold-out or discontinued product

"Not in stock" or "no longer available"

Keep the page with real detail, or redirect to a close replacement

A thin location or service page

A heading and a sentence

Write the page properly, or merge it into one that is

An old address redirected to the home page

The home page is not what the old address was about

Redirect to a close match, or let it return 404

Should you redirect every dead page to the home page?

No. Redirect a dead page to the page that replaced it, or to the closest match. Google's guidance for a page that has moved is a 301 "to the new location", and for a page removed with no replacement, it says a 404 is not necessarily a problem. For an old address about a specific page, the home page is neither.


Think of the visitor who clicked an old link to a specific product or post. Landing on the home page tells them nothing about what they wanted. A clear "not found" page with links to your main sections helps them more, and gives Google the honest answer.


How to see the page the way Google saw it

For this status, what Google saw on the page is the whole question, and Search Console can show you a screenshot of it. Google's help points to the live test for exactly that reason. These steps take you from the row in the report to that screenshot.


  1. In Search Console, open Indexing, then Pages, and click "Soft 404".

  2. Inspect one of the example addresses.

  3. Click Test live URL.

  4. Click View tested page, then look at the screenshot.

  5. Ask: does this look like a real page with content, or like an empty or error page? If the screenshot is blank or broken, the problem may be in how the page loads, not in what you wrote.

How to fix a soft 404, step by step

Decide what the page should be, then make the page and its status code agree. A page that should exist needs content Google can see. A page that should not exist needs to return 404 or 410, or to redirect somewhere that genuinely replaces it. Do the decision first; the fix follows from it.


  1. Open the page and the screenshot from the live test side by side.

  2. Decide: should this page exist?

  3. If yes, add the content that makes it a real page: the products, the text, the details a visitor came for.

  4. If it moved, set a 301 redirect to its new address.

  5. If it is gone with a close replacement, redirect to the replacement.

  6. If it is gone with no replacement, delete it so the address returns 404 or 410, and remove links to it from your own site.

  7. Run the live test again, then request indexing for pages you kept.


Step 6's second half is the easiest part to miss. If your own menus still link to a deleted page, Google keeps finding it.


Seven steps to fix a soft 404, with step 6, removing links to a deleted page from your own site, called out as the easiest part to miss.

Fixing soft 404s on Wix and Squarespace

Both platforms publish help on soft 404s, and both point at the same two culprits: a page with too little on it, and a page whose text reads like an error. Here is what each says, as their help pages read on November 2, 2026, and where each one's redirect tool lives.


Wix. Wix's help on this error says Google can flag a page "if it thinks your site pages contain little or no original content," and that soft 404s on pages you deleted, such as old products or posts, are "normal behaviour and will be resolved eventually." For a page that should stay, add content and request indexing. For a page that moved, use the URL Redirect Manager in your SEO dashboard. A renamed page already has its redirect, because Wix makes one when a slug changes; a renamed blog post does not, so add that one yourself.


Squarespace. Squarespace's help says a good page can trip this if Google "misinterprets text on that page as error messaging," and lists phrases to look for: "no longer available", "item not available", "not in stock" and "does not exist". Reword those, and use Squarespace's URL mappings, in Developer tools, for any page that moved.


How to confirm the fix (and how long it takes)

For a page you kept, the live test screenshot should now show the content, and the page should move out of the soft 404 row after Google's next crawl. For a page you removed, URL Inspection should report a 404. Request indexing for kept pages; removed ones need nothing more than time.


For a batch, use Validate fix on the "Soft 404" row once all are done. It shows Started, then Passed or Failed, and Google says it "typically takes up to about two weeks." A removed page counts as fixed under the Other state, so deleting a page will not hold validation up.


Other "page not indexed" reasons, compared with a soft 404

A soft 404 is about what Google found on the page. Several other reasons are about whether Google got to the page at all, or which copy it kept. The closest relative is the plain "Not found (404)" row, which is the honest version of this one; the table covers the family of statuses we explain in full.


Status

Compared with a soft 404

Crawled - currently not indexed

Google found content but chose not to index it; a soft 404 means it found next to none

Discovered - currently not indexed

Google has not looked at the page yet

Page with redirect

The address forwards on; done well, it is one of the fixes for a soft 404

Excluded by 'noindex' tag

The page asked to be left out

Blocked by robots.txt

Google was not allowed to fetch it

Alternate page with proper canonical tag

A copy, pointed correctly at its main page

Duplicate without user-selected canonical

A copy Google chose between itself

Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user

A copy where Google overrode your choice

Ways to find empty-looking pages before Google does

Soft 404s come from pages that are thin, empty or worded like an error, and you can find them before Google reports them. A crawl lists pages with very little text and pages that return the wrong status code. These options run from Google's own reports to a full review of your site.


Option

What it shows about soft 404s

Cost

Page indexing report

Pages Google already flagged, as a sample

Free

URL Inspection live test

A screenshot of one page as Google renders it

Free

A crawler, such as Screaming Frog

Status codes and thin pages among those it crawls

Free version crawls up to 500 URLs, as of November 2, 2026

Capron Media (ours)

Free check, with a free Lite subscription: a short, plain read of a website: what to fix first across the site, on its home page, and in its local results

Free


For every issue on the site with its fix, the SEO Audit on our SEO audit services page goes through it all, and a person checks it before it reaches you; our pricing page lists the cost. Our guides to an SEO audit and to a technical SEO audit explain each in full.


Questions about 404s and soft 404s

What does the "404 page not found" error mean?

It means the server looked for the address and has nothing there. Your site shows its "not found" page and sends the 404 status code with it. For a page you removed on purpose, that is the correct answer.


How do I fix a 404 error on my website?

If the page moved, redirect the old address to the new one with a 301. If it is gone for good, a 404 is fine, but remove links to it from your own pages. If it should exist, restore it.


Does our own site return a real 404?

We checked on November 2, 2026. A made-up address on our site returned status 404 with our "not found" page, not a 200. That is the setup that keeps missing pages from showing up as soft 404s. You can check yours the same way with any header checker.


Is a soft 404 bad for my whole site?

Google's help does not say it harms other pages. The cost is the page itself: Google will not index it. If many pages are affected, look for what they share, such as an empty template.


From Capron Media: the free Lite subscription

The Lite dashboard for a made-up bakery: site health counts across 48 pages, and cards to connect Search Console and Analytics. Example data.
Example data from a made-up bakery.

See what to fix first on any website

Your own site doesn't use up a check. You can check up to three other sites, each once every 30 days. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.



Written by Spencer Capron, founder of Capron Media, a Middleborough, Massachusetts SEO service for small business owners. Spencer is HubSpot SEO II certified, holds CompTIA Security+, and has run recurring SEO programs for 30+ small-business clients. He wrote this post in collaboration with our AI agents, and he reviews everything published here.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page