top of page

SEO Competitor Analysis: How to Do One for a Small Business, With a Template

Nov 9
8 min read

Updated: Nov 12

A title graphic reading SEO Competitor Analysis beside a mock results page of three illustrative competitor results.

By Spencer Capron, founder of Capron Media. Published November 9, 2026.


An SEO competitor analysis looks at the websites that rank above yours for the searches your customers make, what those pages do that yours do not, and what to change first. Your search competitors are whoever ranks for those searches, and that may not be the business across the street. You can do one free, with the template below.


What is an SEO competitor analysis?

An SEO competitor analysis compares your website with the sites that rank for the searches you want to win. It looks at four things: the searches each site ranks for, the page that ranks, the sites that link to it, and how well the site is built. A business competitor analysis looks at prices and products instead.


If you have seen the "four P's" in competitor analysis, they are the marketing mix: product, price, place and promotion. They describe a rival business. An SEO competitor analysis adds the question the four P's leave out: who shows up when your customer searches.


It is one part of a full SEO audit, which also checks your own site's content, technical health and local results.


From Capron Media: the free Lite subscription

Lite rankings card for a made-up bakery: 11 search terms in the top 3, up 8, with a rising trend line. Example data.
Example data from a made-up bakery.

Comparing tools? See your rankings free

See where your site shows up in Google search, without buying a separate tool. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.



Who are your SEO competitors? How to find them in 10 minutes

To find your SEO competitors, search the five things your customers are most likely to type, and write down every website on the first page. The sites that come up for more than one search are your search competitors. Count directories, marketplaces and review sites too: they compete for the same clicks even if they sell nothing like you.


  1. Write down five searches. Use the words a customer would use, such as "custom cakes near me". If you have Google Search Console, its Performance report shows the searches your site already appears for.

  2. Search each one as a customer would, from your own area, because local results change with where the searcher is.

  3. Note the first page for each search: the map results and the ordinary results below them.

  4. Mark every site that appears more than once. Those three to five sites are the ones to study.


A made-up example of a bakery's two searches, where a rival bakery, a local directory and a supermarket bakery page come up, with the four steps for finding your search competitors.
This is a made-up example: the bakery, the town and the results are invented to show the method.

We did this at Capron Media for this post. On November 2, 2026, the first three ordinary results for "seo competitor analysis" were free tool pages from Exploding Topics, Similarweb and Backlinko, not other SEO agencies. Our search competitors for this page are tool makers.


How to do an SEO competitor analysis, step by step

To do an SEO competitor analysis, pick three to five search competitors, find the searches they win that you do not, compare their winning page with yours, look at who links to them, check how their site is built, and end with three actions. Write each finding in the template as you go, so the work ends in a plan.


  1. List your search competitors. Use the three to five sites from the 10-minute search above.

  2. Find the searches they win that you do not. Search each of your five customer searches and note which competitor ranks where you do not. A paid tool can list these gaps for you; this is sometimes called a keyword gap or content gap analysis.

  3. Compare their page with yours for one search. Look at what kind of page wins (a guide, a list, a service page, a tool), which questions it answers, whether it shows prices or photos, and when it was last updated.

  4. Look at who links to them. A free backlink checker shows some of the sites that link to a competitor. Links from local papers, suppliers or associations are the kind you could earn too.

  5. Check how their site is built. Run their page and yours through Google's PageSpeed Insights, and open both on your phone.

  6. Decide your first three actions. One page to improve, one page to create, and one link to earn. Put each one in the last column of the template.


The six steps of an SEO competitor analysis, from listing your search competitors to deciding your first three actions.

SEO competitor analysis template

Here is an SEO competitor analysis template to copy into a spreadsheet or a notebook. Add one row per competitor. The last column matters most: an analysis that ends without "what we will do" is research, not a plan.


Competitor

Searches they win

Page that wins

Why it wins

What we will do

















A filled example is in the worked example below.


Free and paid tools for competitor analysis

You can start a competitor analysis with free tools: Google search itself, your own Search Console, and PageSpeed Insights. Paid tools add lists of the searches and links a competitor has, which saves time on larger sites. The prices below were read on each vendor's own page on the date shown, and they change.


Tool

What it helps with

Free option

Paid price, and the date we checked

Google search

Who ranks for each of your customer searches

Free

Free

Google Search Console

The searches your own site appears for (not a competitor's)

Free

Free

PageSpeed Insights

Speed of your page and a competitor's page

Free

Free

Exploding Topics competitor analysis tool

A snapshot of a competitor's top pages and keywords

Up to 3 competitor reports a day, no account

Not priced on that page (as of November 2, 2026)

Semrush

Competitor analysis and keyword research

A $0 plan: 1 demo project and 10 reports a day

SEO plan $139 a month billed monthly, or $117.33 a month billed annually (as of November 2, 2026)

Ahrefs

Competitor backlinks and organic keywords

A free version of its Backlink Checker

Lite plan $129 a month billed monthly (as of November 2, 2026)

SE Ranking

Competitor research and rank tracking

14-day free trial

Core plan $129 a month billed monthly, or $103.20 a month billed annually (as of November 2, 2026)

Screaming Frog SEO Spider

Crawls a site to show its pages, titles and structure

Up to 500 URLs per crawl

$279 per licence per year (as of November 2, 2026)

Capron Media (ours)

Lite subscription free check: "A short, plain read of a website: what to fix first across the site, on its home page, and in its local results."

Free checks come with a free Lite subscription.

Costs nothing, for as long as you keep it.


On a free check, "Competitors and gaps" is locked; the full SEO Audit includes it. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.


The tools are listed by type, not ranked. For a wider look at audit tools, see our guide to SEO audit tools.


How much does competitor analysis cost?

An SEO competitor analysis can cost nothing but your time if you use Google search and the free tools above. Paid tools charge a monthly plan, from the prices in the table. An agency or consultant sets its own price for the work, so ask what the report includes and whether it ends with actions.


If you would rather have it done for you, our SEO audit services page describes the full SEO Audit, which includes "Competitors and gaps". It can audit "your own site, a client's, a competitor's, or any other." For what each option costs, see our pricing.


How often should you do an SEO competitor analysis?

How often is your call; there is no fixed rule. A practical rhythm for a small business is a full pass once a quarter, plus a quick check whenever a rival suddenly passes you, before you publish a page you care about, and after you change your site. Keep the old template so you can compare.


Example: a competitor analysis for a made-up bakery

Here is how the template looks when it is filled in. This is a made-up example: the bakery, the town and the results are invented to show the method. The bakery searched "custom cakes near me" and "birthday cakes" from its own town and wrote down who came up.


Competitor

Searches they win

Page that wins

Why it wins

What we will do

Example: another bakery's website

custom cakes near me

A "Custom cakes" page

One page just for custom cakes, with photos, flavors and how to order

Create our own custom cakes page with photos and an order form

Example: a local directory

birthday cakes

A list of bakeries in town

Reviews and a map on one page

Check our listing there is correct and complete

Example: a supermarket bakery page

birthday cakes

A cake ordering page

Shows prices and pickup times

Add prices or a "from" price and pickup times to our cakes page


A filled SEO competitor analysis template for a made-up bakery, with three competitors and one action for each.

The bakery's first three actions come straight from the last column: one page to create, one page to improve, and one listing to check.


What to do after your SEO competitor analysis

After an SEO competitor analysis, work on the three actions in your template, then check your own site for what stops it from ranking at all. A competitor's page can only show you what to add; a content audit of your own pages and a backlink audit of your own links show what to fix first.


For the full list of checks to run on your own site, see our SEO checklist.


From Capron Media: the free Lite subscription

The Lite dashboard for a made-up bakery: site health counts across 48 pages, and cards to connect Search Console and Analytics. Example data.
Example data from a made-up bakery.

See what to fix first on any website

Your own site doesn't use up a check. You can check up to three other sites, each once every 30 days. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.



SEO competitor analysis: questions people ask

Can you provide a template for a competitive analysis report?

Yes. The SEO competitor analysis template above has five columns: competitor, searches they win, page that wins, why it wins, and what we will do. Copy it into a spreadsheet, add one row per competitor, and fill the last column with no more than three actions.


What goes in a competitor analysis?

For search, it covers who ranks for your customer searches, the searches they win that you do not, the page that wins and why, the sites that link to it, and how fast and usable their site is. It ends with what you will do about each one.


Is there a free tool for competitor analysis in SEO?

Yes. Google search is the free starting point, since it shows who ranks today. Search Console shows your own searches, and PageSpeed Insights tests any page's speed. Several paid tools have a free plan or trial, listed in the table above with the date we checked.


What is the best tool for competitor analysis?

There is no single best tool. For a small business, Google search and a notebook answer the main question, which is who ranks and why. A paid tool earns its cost when you need lists of a competitor's searches and links across many pages.


What AI tools are available for competitor analysis?

General AI assistants can read and summarize two pages you give them and suggest differences. What they say about rankings is only as good as the search data they can reach, so check any ranking claim against the results page yourself.


Related reading: how to run a technical SEO audit, and what keyword cannibalization is when two of your own pages compete.


Written by Spencer Capron, founder of Capron Media, a Middleborough, Massachusetts SEO service for small business owners. Spencer is HubSpot SEO II certified, holds CompTIA Security+, and has run recurring SEO programs for 30+ small-business clients. He wrote this post in collaboration with our AI agents, and he reviews everything published here.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page