top of page

Search Engine Marketing Metrics: Which Numbers to Act On, and What to Do When They Move

Sep 9
5 min read

Updated: Nov 7

By Spencer Capron, founder of Capron Media. Updated October 30, 2026.


Search engine marketing metrics are the numbers your paid search ads produce: what they cost, how often they show, how often people click, and what those clicks turn into. A report can hold dozens of them. This page is about the few worth acting on, and what to do when each one moves. What a full report contains, section by section, is in what a search engine marketing report includes.


Five people at a table with laptops and printed charts, reviewing numbers on a wall screen.

Which search engine marketing metrics matter most?

Conversions and cost per conversion matter most, because they measure what you bought the ads for: calls, forms, bookings or sales, and what each one cost. Every other number explains why those two moved. Click-through rate, cost per click, impression share and search terms are diagnostic: read them when the result changes, not instead of it.


A conversion is the action you count as a result. Cost per conversion is spend divided by conversions. Where sales values are tracked, return on ad spend compares the revenue with the spend. These numbers are only as good as the conversion tracking behind them, so check that first: a phone call that never gets counted makes a working campaign look like a failing one.


From Capron Media: the free Lite subscription

Lite winners and losers card for a made-up bakery: "sourdough near me" up 6, "birthday cakes" up 3, "gluten free bread" down 4, volatility high. Example data.
Example data from a made-up bakery.

Is it working? See which searches moved

See which searches moved up and which moved down since the last check. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.



How do you know if your search ads are working?

Your search ads are working if they produce conversions at a cost per conversion you can afford, given what a customer is worth to you. Compare this month with last month and with the same month last year, in the same format. If conversions hold and the cost per conversion falls or stays flat at a level you can afford, the account is working.


If you cannot tell, the problem is often measurement, not the ads. Ask three questions: are calls and forms being counted as conversions, does every campaign show its own cost per conversion, and do you know roughly what a new customer is worth? Without those three, no metric can tell you whether the spend is paying.


What do the main SEM metrics mean, and what do you do when they move?

Each metric answers one question, and each has a usual first place to look when it moves. The table uses Google's own definitions. Read it from the bottom of the funnel up: start with conversions, and only move to the rows above when conversions or their cost change.


Metric

What it is

If it moves the wrong way, look first at

Conversions

The actions you count as results

Conversion tracking, then the landing page

Cost per conversion

Spend divided by conversions

Which campaign or search terms used the money

Conversion rate

Conversions per ad interaction, as a percentage

The landing page and whether the search matched the offer

Cost per click

What you paid for each click; never more than your maximum bid

Bids and competition for the keyword

Click-through rate

Clicks divided by impressions

The ad text and whether it matches the search

Impression share

Impressions received divided by the total you were eligible for

Budget and bids

Search terms

What people actually typed when your ad showed

Negative keywords for searches that never fit

What is a good click-through rate for search ads?

There is no single good click-through rate. Google says a good CTR "is relative to what you're advertising and on which networks", so the useful comparison is your own ads against each other and against last month. A rising CTR with falling conversions means the ad attracts clicks the page does not convert.


That last pattern is the one to catch. It often means the ad promises something the landing page does not deliver, or the ad shows for searches that were never going to buy. The search terms report tells you which.


Why is Quality Score not a KPI?

Because Google says so. Google describes Quality Score as "a diagnostic tool", scored from 1 to 10 for each keyword, and states that it "is not a key performance indicator and should not be optimized or aggregated with the rest of your data." Use it to find a weak ad or landing page, not to judge the account.


A report that leads with an average Quality Score is leading with a number Google tells advertisers not to average. Ask instead for conversions and cost per conversion by campaign.


Which SEM metrics can you ignore?

You can ignore any number that is not connected to a result. Impressions and clicks on their own, an average Quality Score, and an account-wide average that hides one good campaign and one wasteful one are the usual suspects. They are not wrong, but none of them tells you whether the spend paid off.


  • Impressions and clicks without conversions. They show activity, not results.

  • An average across the whole account. Split it by campaign and by device; one campaign can carry the rest.

  • A month with no record of changes. If you do not know what was changed in the account, you cannot tell whether a number moved because of the work or because of the season.

  • Results inside the attribution window you did not set. Ask which window the report uses before comparing two months.

What should you ask your agency about the numbers?

Ask for conversions and cost per conversion by campaign, the search terms that used money without converting, and a written note of what was changed and why. Those three show you whether the account is being managed or only reported. A good report answers them without being asked.


Ask too what the agency will change next month because of these numbers. A report that ends without a next step is a summary, not management. How often reports should arrive, and what a complete one contains, is covered in what a search engine marketing report includes.


Where can you see your SEM metrics?

Your paid search metrics live in your Google Ads account, and the visits and conversions they lead to live in Google Analytics. Unpaid search results are a different set of numbers, in Search Console. Here is where each kind of number lives, including the organic side we work on.


Where

What you see there

Google Ads

Spend, impressions, clicks, cost per click, conversions, Quality Score, search terms

Google Analytics

What visitors from ads did on your site, if it is linked to Google Ads

Google Search Console

Your unpaid results: clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position

A reporting dashboard

Several sources combined in one view, set up by you or your agency

Capron Media (ours)

Lite subscription (free): no ads numbers, because we do not run ads. Your own site's rankings, map results, site health and links. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.


Capron Media does not run ads; ads are on our not-included list. Our work is the unpaid side, done every week on the site you already own. If your report has an organic section and the numbers are not answering the question you have, book a free call about your site. It takes about 15 minutes, and it is about whether we are a fit for you.


From Capron Media: the free Lite subscription

The Lite dashboard for a made-up bakery: site health counts across 48 pages, and cards to connect Search Console and Analytics. Example data.
Example data from a made-up bakery.

Now set a goal and follow your progress

Set a goal and follow your rankings against it. Targets are an estimate, not a promise. Lite does not include the work on your site. Starter does.



Written by Spencer Capron, founder of Capron Media, a Middleborough, Massachusetts SEO service for small business owners. Spencer is HubSpot SEO II certified, holds CompTIA Security+, and has run recurring SEO programs for 30+ small-business clients. He wrote this post in collaboration with our AI agents, and he reviews everything published here.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page